Winter 2017 Issue of Civil War Book Review Available Online
This issue’s feature content includes a diverse offering that ranges from the lives of women in antebellum of Natchez, Miss., to military engineering. Though diverse, the winter issue’s offerings challenge the reader to look beyond the conventional frames of historical reference by closely examining the lives of non-elite women, the culture behind military logistics, the global exchange of ideas and the morality of nineteenth-century decisions makers.
Mark Smith’s review of Thomas F. Army Jr.’s “Engineering Victory: How Technology Won the Civil War” praises the book for its examination of a “culture of improvisation” that saturated the North. The antebellum North’s commitment to common school reforms and embrace of the lyceum movement, Army argues, made the Union army amiable to a system of “bottom-up technical innovations,” which proved essential to the Union’s victory.
In Joyce Broussard’s “Stepping Lively in Place: The Not-Married, Free Women of Civil-War-Era Natchez, Mississippi,” the winter issue turns from the cultural concerns to social considerations. As reviewer Jean Baker points it, society expected Natchez’s unmarried, free women to be dutiful wives above all else. These expectations meant that unmarried women, black or white, needed to operate “with amazing dexterity” if they intended to remain unmarried property holders before and after the Civil War.
The Civil War Treasures column considers the rich documentary sources left by one antebellum family from Clinton, La. The Wall Family Papers, as LSU Special Collection Librarians Hans Rasmussen and Meghann Wollitz explained, feature vivid commentary by a southeast Louisiana family who experienced heavy wartime losses, imprisonment, and maintained familial responsibilities under military occupation.
Further expanding the boundaries of historical convention is Vitor Izechkson’s “Slavery and War in the Americas: Race, Citizenship, and State Building in the United States and Brazil, 1861-1870.” Though a number of scholars have previously examined connections between the U.S. and Brazil, reviewer Enrico Dal Lago noted, Izechkson’s analysis is path breaking for its chronological emphasis. Few scholars have devoted book length studies to the western hemisphere’s dominant slave powers. In closely comparing these slaveholding powers in wartime, Izechson turns conventional wisdom on its head by recognizing that the American Civil War wrought incredible social change through emancipation and the Confederacy’s defeat. Brazil’s War of the Triple Alliance, however, brought no such changes for that country’s enslaved. These conclusions, Dal Lago pointed out, enabled Izechson to convincingly paint the American Civil War as a total war because of the social changes it wrought.
Brazil, slavery, and war all appear in Matthew Karp’s “This Vast Slaveholding Empire: Slaveholders at the Helm of American Foreign Policy.” In an interview with Karp, CWBR discussed how U.S. slaveholders secured their interests in human property through their long command over U.S. foreign policy. Threatened by Britain’s anti-slavery policy, U.S. slaveholders looked beyond their nation’s border to secure and justify slavery. American slaveholders found scholarly and political justifications for slavery through close engagement with Europe’s intellectuals and that continent’s growing use of colonial labor. As William J. Cooper, who reviews “This Vast Southern Empire” in this issue, found that one of the book’s most important features is its convincing portrait of slaveholders as cosmopolitan, but conservative men who preferred foreign policy to filibustering.
CWBR’s resident Lincoln expert, Frank J. Williams, tackled Thomas L. Carson’s “Lincoln’s Ethics.” As Williams makes clear, Carson’s background as a philosopher and expert on moral relativism is the book’s cardinal virtue. Carson’s professional background infuses familiar debates about Lincoln’s thoughts on slavery and race with new energy.
Inspired by a panel, titled “The Perennial Problem of Poor Whites during the Civil War Era,” at the 2016 Southern Historical Association’s conference and the lively discussion that followed, this issue begins a new, and hopefully ongoing series, about poor southern whites in the generations before and after the Civil War. Gary Edwards begins this series with an essay about the political identity of poor whites during Reconstruction.
CWBR is published in the months of February, May, August and November. To receive email reminders of upcoming issues and special features on the website, click on “Sign me up for CWBR Updates!” link at the bottom of any page in the journal. From there, readers can provide contact information to receive these e-mail reminders. Contact information will not be shared with any third party.
CWBR is the journal of record for new or newly reprinted books about the antebellum, Civil War and Reconstruction eras, and is a project of the United States Civil War Center, LSU Libraries Special Collections. A reader’s survey can be accessed through the CWBR homepage, www.cwbr.com.
Contact Ernie Ballard
LSU Media Relations