Revolutionary Thinker
Leon Trotsky's Great-Granddaughter Is
Following Her Own Path to Greatness
By Guy Gugliotta
Washington Post Staff Writer
Thursday, August 21, 2003; Page C01
Nora Volkow was born three years after Stalin died, and 16 years
after the Soviet dictator sent a student with an ice ax to kill her
great-grandfather. Her grandmother committed suicide, and her
grandfather was shot to death in a Stalinist prison. She grew up in
Mexico City knowing that her family was both steeped in greatness and
marked by tragedy.
Today, Volkow is the director of the National Institute on Drug
Abuse and one of the United States' leading experts on the science of
drug addiction. "I've studied alcohol, cocaine, methamphetamine, heroin,
marijuana and more recently obesity. There's a pattern in compulsion,"
she says. "I've never come across a single person that was addicted that
wanted to be addicted. Something has happened in their brains that has
led to that process, and I want to know what it is."
By all accounts, Volkow is an inspired, and sometimes
electrifying, thinker. Oh, and she also is the great-granddaughter of
Russian revolutionary Leon Trotsky.
Being the descendant of somebody famous can be a blessing. Barry
Bonds inherited father Bobby's baseball ability and surpassed him by an
order of magnitude. Legions of Kennedys, not to mention the current
President Bush, have had an entree into politics because of their
lineage.
But Volkow went her own way. She graduated No. 1 in her class at
Mexico City's immense National University, and over the course of two
decades ran the life sciences department at Brookhaven National
Laboratory, became a member of the National Academy of Sciences and
wrote groundbreaking papers on brain imaging and addiction with hardly a
thought about what Leon Trotsky could or could not have done for her.
"My father didn't like to speak of Trotsky, because I think he had
been so traumatized, so he really kept us away from politics," she says.
"He never told me any of those stories until I was grown up."
She acknowledges that the family history is "fascinating" but
leaves the listener to fill in the political and spiritual blanks. Leon
Trotsky, in death as in life, was an ideological lightning rod for an
entire century. Even direct descendants know better than to tell
posterity how to think about him.
A Doer
and a Thinker
Nora Volkow now gives speeches, attends multiple meetings and schmoozes
lawmakers on Capitol Hill. She talks to cops and counselors, moving from
her beloved research to embrace the community side of the drug war. "My
life is upside down!" she says with a laugh, but she doesn't regret it:
"I like challenges."
"She just burns it up," said Al Brandenstein, chief scientist of
the White House Office of National Drug Control Policy and a longtime
admirer. "She's incapable of sitting still."
Three months after arriving at NIDA's Bethesda headquarters,
Volkow clearly has not settled in. Her office is sunny, airy -- and
almost empty. There are books and some nice furniture, but the
validating staples of official Washington -- diplomas, framed thank-you
letters and, most of all, grip-and-grin photos of the office occupant
with other powerful people -- are nowhere in evidence.
Instead, Volkow has brought in paintings -- including a couple of
her own -- which sit on the floor, propped against the wall, awaiting
hammer and nails. Like Volkow herself -- an attractive woman with an
elfish grin and dark eyes flashing with intelligence -- the pictures are
bold, bright and disturbing. And they are transparently Mexican, the
only things in her office that give away her background.
"That's my dog, my Rottweiler," she said, pointing to one
painting. "She died when she was 14 years old. She liked to play that
she was a fierce dog, but she was a very gentle creature." She paused.
"I like to be a little bit playful."
But there's nothing playful about the painting, a large sepia
canvas bearing the skeletal outline of a huge hound bent toward the
ground as if scavenging a corpse.
Pressed further, Volkow explains that she paints not for
relaxation or exorcism, but for elasticity of mind -- "to break my
patterns of thinking," she says. "Does it make me think differently
about science? I'd like to think it does, but I may be deceiving
myself."
Volkow thinks about thinking. This is where it has led her:
Using imaging technology to track the activities of the human
brain, she was the first to suggest that prolonged treatment with
therapeutic drugs blunted normal thought patterns and emotions in
schizophrenics, even as the worst of their hallucinations subsided.
She was the first to notice that cocaine addiction triggered
tiny strokes -- that cocaine was toxic -- an idea so radical at the time
that it took her three years before a journal agreed to publish it.
And more recently she has suggested that the brains of drug
addicts have less sensitive pleasure centers -- known as dopamine
receptors -- leading them to take drugs for the sensory jolt that
non-addicts may feel without stimulus.
"She knows how to look at data better than anyone I've ever
seen," says Brookhaven chemist Joanna Fowler, Volkow's longtime
collaborator. "When she was studying cocaine, everyone else was focusing
on how rapidly it was getting to the brain, but she focused on how fast
it was leaving the brain -- making the receptors crave another hit."
Volkow has published more papers -- about 275 -- than anyone else
in her field. She had administrative experience as Brookhaven's
associate director for life sciences and chairman of its medical
department. She was a full professor of psychiatry at Long Island's
Stony Brook University. Given her credentials, the choice of Volkow to
head NIDA appears to have been almost a no-brainer.
And how she got there makes for an interesting story.
The
Father
The hero of the piece is Esteban Volkow Bronstein, now 78, a retired
chemical engineer. He moved from Turkey to Mexico City in 1940 to join
his grandfather, Leon Trotsky, in the large, high-ceilinged house at
Viena 45 in Coyoacan, a well-to-do neighborhood of distinctive homes.
By that time, most of the family was either dead or marked for
death -- hounded into exile, pursued across continents or killed in the
Stalinist purges of the 1930s. Esteban's grandmother -- Trotsky's first
wife -- died in exile in Siberia. His father and uncle -- Trotsky's
sons-in-law -- were imprisoned and shot.
His mother was able to take an ailing Esteban -- then called Sieva
-- out of the Soviet Union to join her father in Turkey, but her
citizenship was revoked before she could return for her daughter. She
committed suicide. Her sister died of tuberculosis at age 26, and her
niece disappeared.
One of Trotsky's sons by his second marriage died young in a Paris
hospital. The second -- an apolitical engineer -- died in a Stalinist
concentration camp.
"So my father has no family," recounts Nora Volkow. "My father
ends up with Trotsky in Mexico because no one else was alive."
By 1940 Trotsky had been on the run for 11 years, since he lost a
final power struggle to Joseph Stalin. Trotsky was one of the leaders of
the October Revolution and served as the Soviet Union's first foreign
minister and first war minister and was viewed as the second most
powerful person in the Revolutionary government, until the death of
Vladimir I. Lenin in 1924. Stalin sent him and his doctrine of
"permanent revolution" into exile -- to Turkey, France, Norway and,
finally, in 1937, to Mexico City. For two years, Trotsky and his second
wife, Natalya, lived with the Mexican muralist Diego Rivera and his
wife, the artist Frida Kahlo, in Kahlo's Coyoacan home. The couples had
a falling out -- probably because Trotsky was having an affair with
Kahlo -- and the Trotskys moved to the Calle Viena house a few blocks
away.
Stalin was actively hunting Trotsky by then, and Trotsky's
followers built a wall around the Viena house and installed a sentry
box. A band of Stalinist hirelings attacked the compound with machine
guns one night, but the guards drove them off. Esteban was in the
bedroom next to his grandparents when bullets splattered the walls.
A few weeks later, on Aug. 20, 1940, a Soviet agent using the name
Ramon Mercader presented himself as an eager young Marxist acolyte,
gained access to Trotsky's study and buried an ice ax in his head.
Trotsky died the next day.
What Esteban Volkow felt can only be imagined. "I've asked him
those questions, but he kept that life very separate, and I think it was
hard for him to deal with it," his daughter says. "It took him a while."
Trotsky's House
Nora Volkow was born in the Calle Viena house on March 27, 1956, and
lived there until she graduated from high school. It is perhaps a
testament to Esteban Volkow's ability to hold his demons at bay that his
daughter took obvious pleasure living in a house that for her was never
haunted, but simply home.
"There were rooms that Trotsky used for visitors, and my father
transformed those into the house where we lived," Volkow says. "He
wanted us not to touch anything in the [museum portion of the] house --
not that we always followed the rules." She smiles. "Actually when I
needed to study, I would go into Natalya's office, because I was not
allowed to go into Trotsky's studio."
Esteban lived comfortably as a Mexican citizen, and though he
maintained the Trotsky house as a private museum, he stayed away from
politics, "sensitive not to jeopardize his own family in any way,"
Volkow says. "What I learned about Trotsky, I learned by reading and
interacting with family friends, and from living in the house, not from
my father."
Trotsky was born Lev Davidovich Bronstein of Jewish parents.
Esteban Volkow uses Bronstein in his own name, but does not practice
Judaism. Neither does his daughter, although she takes pride in a
background that is half Jewish and half Roman Catholic from her
Spanish-born mother.
"I have the two great religions," Volkow says, but she claims
neither. "Trotsky was very sensitive to how identities segregate people,
so he didn't identify himself as Jewish. He said he belonged to the
human race, and I was never given any type of identification as
belonging to the Jewish or the Christian."
Only once did history intrude on Nora Volkow's childhood. A star
student who had been fully committed to science since she was 5 years
old, she was offered a scholarship to study in Russia when she graduated
from high school at the English-language Modern American School.
"I wanted to go," Volkow says. "My father was extremely disturbed,
but being an adolescent, I was ignoring his advice. Then friends of the
family said, 'Nora, you're putting yourself and your family at risk. You
go to Russia and they can say how open the government is because they
have Trotsky's great-granddaughter there,' " even though Trotsky was
still officially a nonperson.
So instead she entered medical school at the Universidad Nacional
Autonoma de Mexico (UNAM), Mexico's national university, a seemingly odd
choice given her U.S.-style private education and fluent English.
"Yes, but I wanted to be a doctor, and the medical school at UNAM
was very good," she says. And at UNAM she could get her MD in six years,
with no pre-med undergraduate degree, required courses in irrelevant
subjects or other distractions.
She graduated in 1981 as both UNAM's best student and the
"outstanding medical student" of her 2,000-member medical school class,
and was preparing to go to the Massachusetts Institute of Technology on
a PhD fellowship in the fall.
But she got sidetracked. Reading a copy of Scientific American
that summer, she learned about brain imaging -- studying the human brain
in three dimensions by using scanners to detect radioactive tracers
injected into a patient. Different tracers highlighted different brain
activities that provided information on neurological disorders like
stroke, epilepsy, Alzheimer's disease -- and drug addiction.
"You could actually image the human brain alive, and I went wild
about it," Volkow says. The work was being done at New York University
in collaboration with Brookhaven, "so I said to my father, I'm going to
NYU and see if I can volunteer. I didn't know anyone," she says. "I just
got on a plane."
She showed up a few days later in the anteroom of Robert Cancro,
chairman of the NYU School of Medicine's psychiatry department, who met
with her and gave her a job. "Evidently he must have liked me," she
says.
Evidently. "You had to be pretty stupid to miss it, actually,"
recalls Cancro, still the department chairman and a close friend of
Volkow's. "It was clear she was bright, anxious, enthusiastic and you
could see the drive. I mean, after all, I am a psychiatrist."
Volkow's first paper focused on the equipment -- how to use it to
get information on cancerous brain tumors without resorting to surgery.
"Suddenly I have this tool that measures biochemical transformations
without opening up someone and removing a piece of tissue," she recalls,
her voice still hinting at the wonder that these early experiments
evoked.
Then she turned to schizophrenia -- what could brain imaging tell
you about neurological disorders? She showed that medications interacted
with the centers in the schizophrenic brain that governed the disease.
She wanted to know if the interactions were what caused "poverty of
thought," a crippling condition in which schizophrenics lose the ability
to feel pleasure and excitement, and in which the whole thinking process
slows down. Subsequent research has confirmed and extended her findings.
In 1984 she left NYU for an assistant professorship at the
University of Texas Health Science Center at Houston, expecting to
continue her research. "They had a fantastic imaging center," Volkow
recalls, but as it happened, "there wasn't a single schizophrenic in the
university hospital."
What the hospital did have was cocaine addicts, so Volkow adapted.
"I was probably the first person to use these new technologies for the
investigation of drugs of abuse," she says, but her work was ignored
initially, especially her seminal paper documenting strokes in the
brains of cocaine abusers.
"I started to present these data at meetings, and people didn't
believe it, because there was no evidence that cocaine was toxic," she
says. " 'That's fine,' I said. 'But this is what the data show.' "
She applied for a grant from NIDA to pursue her research and was
turned down; it took three years before the British Journal of
Psychiatry finally published her paper. "This is what happens to you
when you come up with things before their time," Volkow says.
While in Texas, she married Stephen Adler, a high-energy physicist
at the University of Texas at Houston. They moved to Brookhaven, where
both could continue their research.
Volkow was there when the NIDA search committee came knocking. Her
predecessor at NIDA, Alan Leshner, now CEO of the American Association
for the Advancement of Science, regarded her, "without exaggerating, as
the ideal person," he says. "She has taught us a tremendous amount about
the science of addiction, and we need strong leadership to move to the
next level. If I had been able to pick my successor, it would have been
her."
For Volkow, the biggest question was whether she could stand to
curtail her own research, but in the end "there was no way to say no,"
she says. "I spent 25 years studying drug addiction, and this is really
an opportunity to enforce change with much more impact -- an opportunity
to mold the field and make a difference."
The Old
Country
Volkow, a U.S. citizen since 1993, does not hold dual citizenship but
she returns to Mexico "maybe once a year, now, since my mother died,"
she says. The Mexican government finally took over the Trotsky Museum,
"a great relief" for her father, who no longer has to maintain it.
Esteban Volkow began to come out of his shell in the late 1980s
with the advent of perestroika but maintained he would never
return to Russia. Then, "I guess it was about 10 years ago," his
daughter says, "he gets a call from a friend who says 'Esteban, we have
found your sister.' Everybody thought she was dead."
So he went for a Moscow visit. His sister, Eva, was dying of
cancer. She had heard no news of her family since her mother took
Esteban to Turkey in 1930. "She never knew why she was left behind,"
Volkow says. "She felt abandoned." Eva died two months after her
brother's visit, the last tragedy of the Trotsky diaspora.
But the world has changed.
Last year Nora Volkow and her husband went to St. Petersburg for a
week's vacation. It was her first visit to the city she still calls
Leningrad. She jogged along the Neva River and marveled at the
spectacular palaces and the "megalomania" that created them.
Then she left, her sojourn unremarked and unrecorded in the old
Russian capital. "I wanted to be completely, completely anonymous," she
says.
And she was.
¸ 2003 The Washington Post Company
|